Listen to this post

Power Transmission Towers

Here is Saturday morning’s installment of our update on the Oroville Dam spillway incident and more news about the valley.  In summary, Oroville’s Powerhouse is still not able to produce power; the emergency or auxiliary spillway remains stable; workers continue to add rock and concrete to address the erosion that led to the evacuations; the primary or service spillway is also stable, and is now  evacuating 70,000 cfs from the reservoir; but new storms have started to roll in.

As always, if you find this blog helpful or interesting, please feel free to share it with others who may be interested. And if you would like to be updated when we post a new entry, please add your email on the right or below where it says “stay connected.”

Here’s a recap of the last couple of days of activities surrounding the Oroville Dam spillway incident:

1. On Thursday, DWR reduced outflow from 100,000 cfs to 80,000 cfs from the primary spillway at Oroville Dam in order to remove debris from the diversion pool (which is the body of water into which the spillway dumps water). A key reason to remove debris from the diversion pool is for the eventual reoperation of Hyatt power plant, whose operation would be hindered by debris. The powerplant is an underground hydroelectric facility that should assist in releasing water from Lake Oroville once it restarts (it is capable of releasing up to 13,000 cfs). In further support of removing debris, DWR decreased the releases to 70,000 on Friday.  DWR was doubtful, however, that the power plant could start up by early next week when heavier precipitation is predicted.  While many people might question lowering releases just to support electric production, releases through the hydro facility is also how DWR provides irrigation releases during the summer once the lake level drops significantly.  This graphic from public.tableau.com shows both the inflow (you can see just how massive that storm was last week) and outflow over the past week and a half (see upper graph).  In particular, you can see DWR’s efforts to control and increase releases from the primary spillway despite the ongoing erosion.  (Click here for a good article on possible causes of the erosion of the primary spillway.)  The graphic also shows the lake level compared to the elevation of the emergency spillway (lower graph).  (Click here for the original.)

Oroville graphs

 

2. DWR continues to reinforce sections of the emergency spillway whose sudden erosion led to last weekend’s evacuations. We learned on Friday that there are four priority sites for repair, and each is advancing well as follows:  site 1 – 100% complete; site 2 – 50% complete; site 3 – 75% complete; and site 4 – 90% complete, all as of Friday afternoon.  With 70,000 cfs of water being released, the reservoir had declined to just under 856 feet by midnight Friday.

3.Without a doubt in some watersheds this is now the wettest year on record.  In the Yuba Watershed, the rainfall thus far this year is at 110% of the average ANNUAL rainfall, and we still have many months of weather to come.  In fact, the inflow into New Bullards Bar Reservoir on the Yuba River this year is already more than the inflow in 2013, 2014, and 2015, combined.  In the Yuba River watershed, there has already been 15 inches more rainfall than the wettest year on record.

4.  Another set of storms arrived on Thursday and could produce heavy precipitation starting Monday. Between Friday and Sunday light to moderate precipitation is anticipated. Heavy precipitation will likely result in higher inflow into Lake Oroville, but the Weather Service has indicated that the anticipated rainfall is still much lower than what we saw last week when the principal spillway first suffered damage.  In this graphic from the National Weather Service (click here for the original), you can see on the top graph the estimated rainfall for the next few days.  Note that each bar is for a six hour period, so you need to add them together to see the estimated total rainfall in a day.  The bottom graph shows the historic and estimated water surface elevations at Gridley.  Note the significant drop off of water surface elevations for this weekend, likely because of projected decreased releases to work on the Hyatt Powerplant.

Feather River forecast at Gridley_2-17-17

5. On Wednesday the Sutter Butte Flood Control Agency, which has constructed levee improvements over the last four years along the west side of the Feather River (downstream of Oroville Dam), authorized $5 million in immediate reinforcement measures just south of Yuba City. The measures, which focus on areas that have not yet been repaired as part of the agency’s larger project, are proactive in light of already high flows in the river and will bolster vulnerable parts of the levee in the event of a more significant release from Oroville Dam.

6. Elsewhere in the Central Valley flood control system, Tyler Island was able to finish reinforcement of the levee that had significantly slumped, thus ending the mandatory evacuation of the Island.  North of the Delta, a number of districts continue to struggle with saturated levees which are significantly seeping or showing many boils.

For more detailed information about current storage, inflow, and outflow from Oroville Dam, we still recommend the California Data Exchange Center.  Additional sources of information on this incident can be found on the DWR website and DWR has shared this phone number for public updates: 530-872-5951.

That’s it for today.  Please check back as we continue to update you on how the system is doing.

 

 

Photo of Scott L. Shapiro Scott L. Shapiro

Scott Shapiro is known for his expertise in flood protection improvement projects throughout California’s Central Valley. He is helping clients with more than a billion dollars in projects in California’s Central Valley and issues involving the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) and the…

Scott Shapiro is known for his expertise in flood protection improvement projects throughout California’s Central Valley. He is helping clients with more than a billion dollars in projects in California’s Central Valley and issues involving the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) throughout the Western United States.

With a special focus on massive flood protection improvement projects, Scott advises clients through regulatory, contractual, financing, and legislative challenges. Acting as general or special counsel, he regularly interacts with senior management at USACE (Headquarters, South Pacific Division, and Sacramento District), the California Department of Water Resources, and the Central Valley Flood Protection Board. He was named to the National Section 408 Task Force and has been invited to give testimony to the National Academies. Scott was instrumental in helping the first regional flood improvement agency that took a basin threatened by flood risk from less than 30-year level of protection to a level of protection approaching 200-year.

Having worked with FEMA on issues of floodplain mapping and levee accreditation for many years, Scott has developed collaborative environments in which he fosters win-win solutions for his clients. He is also currently serving as the lead counsel on a flood insurance rate map (FIRM) appeal and has drafted Federal legislation to modify the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) several times.

Scott is known throughout the region for his extensive litigation experience focusing on cases arising from levee failures. He has litigated levee failures resulting from underseepage, failed encroachments, and rodent burrows as well as briefing levee overtopping cases at the appellate level. Scott is one of the few attorneys with experience litigating flood cases on behalf of plaintiffs as well as defendant government entities.

Photo of Andrea P. Clark Andrea P. Clark

Andrea Clark specializes in water rights and flood control, serving as general counsel to a variety of public agencies from local reclamation districts and water districts to regional joint powers authorities.

Public agencies in the water and flood control fields rely on Andrea…

Andrea Clark specializes in water rights and flood control, serving as general counsel to a variety of public agencies from local reclamation districts and water districts to regional joint powers authorities.

Public agencies in the water and flood control fields rely on Andrea for her ability to explain in understandable terms the wide range of issues impacting them, including basic transparency laws (Brown Act and Public Records Act), public bidding and contracting, bond financing, the unique nature of joint powers authorities, and elections. She also regularly counsels clients on water transfers, Proposition 218 compliance, the California Environmental Quality Act, the National Environmental Policy Act, and financing strategies for major capital improvement projects.

With a special expertise in flood control and floodplain management, Andrea is regularly asked to speak on topics ranging from flood insurance to climate change and the future of flood control policy in California. Through her representation of clients in state flood policy and speaking engagements, she has forged strong relationships with key members of the flood control community in California.

Andrea also counsels private clients, including landowners and mutual water companies, on water supply matters, including proceedings before the State Water Resources Control Board, water rights determinations, and contractual disputes with Federal agencies.