Listen to this post

In case you haven’t heard, the National Weather Service is predicting, with high certainty, a very strong El Niño this year. A strong El Niño has already formed with a 90% chance of it strengthening to very strong and a 60% chance of it developing into the strongest since 1950.  If you search El Niño in social media you might conclude that the world is ending; or that we are filming a disaster film; or find yourself laughing at various memes.  But what does El Niño mean from a flood risk management perspective?

Let’s start with what El Niño is not. El Niño is not a storm event. In fact, as my colleague Mark Strudley says, it is not an event at all. El Niño is an indication that certain ocean temperatures are higher than normal. This year, approximately two degrees warmer than usual. So, time to go swimming in the South Pacific, right? Well, it is warmer in the ocean. But to explain a very technical issue very simply, warmer water causes changes in global weather patterns. It tends to mean more water moisture for Southern California and less for the Pacific Northwest and different weather patterns across the U.S. Of course, that doesn’t automatically mean flooding in Southern California which is predicted to be wetter than usual. Will the rain be light, like in London (drizzling all of the time but no big storms)? Or will it be like Palm Springs, with a massive storm that overwhelms the system? The reality is we don’t know. Our modeling isn’t advanced enough to predict so we need to be prepared, like we always are.

Also interesting is what happens between Southern California and the Pacific Northwest. What happens for the Central and Northern Coast of California and the Central Valley of California where some of the greatest flood risk in the U.S. exists? Well, ummm, we also don’t know. The National Weather Service recently reported that of the nine strong or very strong EL Niños since 1950, three have been wet, three have been normal, and three have been dry for Northern California. Kind of hard to make predictions based on those stats. We do expect that we could see stronger atmospheric rivers with higher tides and king tides, but the potential of flooding, as always, will depend on where those storms hit, whether they hit in sequence, what the snow levels do, and many other factors.

But perhaps the best thing about El Niño, and about this El Niño, is the public awareness it brings to flood risk reduction. Folks should have a modest level of fear about flooding and all of this media coverage is helpful in getting people’s attention. Let’s use that attention to drive support for our flood projects. And laugh at the memes when we can.

Photo of Scott L. Shapiro Scott L. Shapiro

Scott Shapiro is known for his expertise in flood protection improvement projects throughout California’s Central Valley. He is helping clients with more than a billion dollars in projects in California’s Central Valley and issues involving the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) and the…

Scott Shapiro is known for his expertise in flood protection improvement projects throughout California’s Central Valley. He is helping clients with more than a billion dollars in projects in California’s Central Valley and issues involving the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) throughout the Western United States.

With a special focus on massive flood protection improvement projects, Scott advises clients through regulatory, contractual, financing, and legislative challenges. Acting as general or special counsel, he regularly interacts with senior management at USACE (Headquarters, South Pacific Division, and Sacramento District), the California Department of Water Resources, and the Central Valley Flood Protection Board. He was named to the National Section 408 Task Force and has been invited to give testimony to the National Academies. Scott was instrumental in helping the first regional flood improvement agency that took a basin threatened by flood risk from less than 30-year level of protection to a level of protection approaching 200-year.

Having worked with FEMA on issues of floodplain mapping and levee accreditation for many years, Scott has developed collaborative environments in which he fosters win-win solutions for his clients. He is also currently serving as the lead counsel on a flood insurance rate map (FIRM) appeal and has drafted Federal legislation to modify the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) several times.

Scott is known throughout the region for his extensive litigation experience focusing on cases arising from levee failures. He has litigated levee failures resulting from underseepage, failed encroachments, and rodent burrows as well as briefing levee overtopping cases at the appellate level. Scott is one of the few attorneys with experience litigating flood cases on behalf of plaintiffs as well as defendant government entities.